Asha Logos video and the issue of Proto-Indo-European vs. Fryas
Posted: 18 Oct 2023, 16:34
In a recently uploaded video, Asha Logos engages in a discourse on the subject of the Aryan peoples, or the Indo-European peoples. The underlying premise of this discussion is the Proto-Indo-European (PIE) theory, which posits that a formerly homogeneous people, speaking a unified language, originated in the Caucasus plains and subsequently disseminated from that region, giving rise to the Germanic languages, Romance languages, and Indo-Iranian languages.
This theory, however, stands at odds with the Oera Linda Book, which is a concrete piece of evidence, not a reconstruction. Consequently, Logos' essay is misguided on its reliance on the PIE theory, forcing him to warp everything to fit that framework. His presumed sole familiarity with American English limits his linguistic research. Nevertheless, he brings up some interesting connections in other contexts; history is more his subject than linguistics. It is important to note that he refers to the Fryas as "the Fryas, or Frisians," which is a misinterpretation of the historical and cultural context of the Fryas.
This theory, however, stands at odds with the Oera Linda Book, which is a concrete piece of evidence, not a reconstruction. Consequently, Logos' essay is misguided on its reliance on the PIE theory, forcing him to warp everything to fit that framework. His presumed sole familiarity with American English limits his linguistic research. Nevertheless, he brings up some interesting connections in other contexts; history is more his subject than linguistics. It is important to note that he refers to the Fryas as "the Fryas, or Frisians," which is a misinterpretation of the historical and cultural context of the Fryas.